Review: Finding Silence in the Noise — The Silence of Unworthy Gods
It’s always an exciting moment when a new book in a beloved series lands on the shelves, and I must admit, I was eager to delve back into the world of Arcane Ascension created by Andrew Rowe. The intricate blend of magic, adventure, and moral dilemmas thoroughly enraptured me in the past. So, when I started The Silence of Unworthy Gods, I approached it with both anticipation and an underlying hope that Rowe would tackle some of the thematic depth the title suggests. Sadly, what unfolded was a 600-page journey that felt more like a stroll through a deserted library than a thrilling expedition into an enchanted realm.
To lay my cards on the table: “Every idle word that men shall speak, they shall give account thereof in the day of judgment,” is a sentiment that resonates deeply with my experience in this book. One could argue that 90% of this narrative is entirely skippable, and in those 500 pages, Rowe’s weaknesses—a struggle with consistent characterization, underdeveloped side characters, bloated technobabble—loom large. While I’ve witnessed subtle shifts and growth in previous installments, here we seem to swim in stagnation. The essence of what makes a compelling fantasy story—creative problem-solving and dramatic turnabouts—appears disappointingly sparse until the last chapters. Yet, by that point, it feels unearned, a forced climax after such a lengthy slog.
Rowe attempts to explore significant themes, namely the "Silence of Unworthy Gods," through the lens of a world grappling with rising tyranny. However, there’s a precarious balance to maintain: a plot that forces characters to grapple with their dilemmas directly leads to impactful outcomes. It’s a ripe theme that could have drawn from splendid depths, yet here it devolves into a B-plot, caught in a hamster wheel of pointless D&D-style downtime. Watching Corin, our main character, meander through mechanistic learning rather than meaningful engagement was disappointing—it seemed to embody the very theme of privilege squandered Rowe critiques.
Despite his protagonist Corin’s potential as an introverted hero navigating the complexities of collective action, we are treated to a character stuck in “Main Character Syndrome.” His choices, while ostensibly noble, often feel self-serving and devoid of genuine growth. Instead of rallying others around him in activism against tyranny—mirroring the notable formation of Dumbledore’s Army in Harry Potter—Corin remains an isolated figure. Even the stakes surrounding him feel disparate, the weight of consequences dissipating into the ether.
Rowe’s prose leaves much to be desired as well: while there are moments—a deft turn of phrase or a laughably ironic twist—that resonate, they become just fleeting sparks of brilliance in an expansive desert of exposition.
If you’ve dedicated yourself to the series, you might still find a nugget of enjoyment in Silence of Unworthy Gods, but I advise proceeding with caution. It may be more prudent to skim a summary rather than plow through the text. For those who appreciate engaging, character-driven narratives, this installment may feel like an arduous task rather than a worthy addition.
In summary, while themes of ethics and action languish under the weight of poor execution, at least we have future releases to hope for a return to form. Perhaps in subsequent chapters of this world, we’ll finally hear the gods speak, or at the very least, see Corin emerge from his solitary existence. For now, I find myself disheartened, left with a solitary "nothing more than words" rating, but still clinging to the hope that creativity will once again leap from the pages.
Discover more about The Silence of Unworthy Gods (Arcane Ascension, #4) on GoodReads >>